I purchased this NYX Super Skinny Eye Marker at Ulta. In years past, I wore liquid liner religiously!! I have gotten away from it though. I watched a makeup video on YouTube that once again spurred my interest and made me wanna try it again. So, when I saw this I grabbed it.I got it in the color carbon black. The tip is super skinny, just like the name says! The color is very much a dark black. It goes on very smoothly. Very easy to make a nice line. It dries to a matte finish which I love. IT STAYS PUT!!! It isn't going anywhere. BUT, as soon as I applied my face wash it came off with no problem. I will definitely be repurchasing this.